The poultry litter beetle, Alphitobius diaperinus, is an important pest of poultry production systems, yet commercial insecticidal gel baits have not been systematically evaluated for its management. We evaluated 10 gel bait formulations against adults from five beetle populations under no-choice and food-choice conditions (50 mg formulation per arena), assessing mortality over 14 days (336) h and short-term bait related and post-exposure responses in separate behavioral assays. Emamectin benzoate and fipronil formulations generally produced the most rapid declines in survival, with LT Gel-bait performance against adult A. diaperinus depends on formulation, population, and feeding context. Integrating mortality kinetics with behavioral observations showed that acute impairment does not necessarily predict longer-term mortality. These findings identify promising bait formulations for field validation and potential incorporation into poultry integrated pest management programs. © 2026 Society of Chemical Industry.